@TheStar

Ruto logging ban is a costly PR ploy

8 months ago, 8 Mar 00:38

By: Kibisu Kabatesi

The newfound eagerness by Deputy President William Ruto to preserve forests, like everything else he does, smacks of mischief. Ruto may be a champion of many things, but environment is not one of them. Not when he fought like a baited cat against the preservation of the Mau water tower not long ago. Not also when public perception has it there is no land he didn’t salivate over. And I loved it when he let slip the sound bite that his “track record on environment is known”. This notwithstanding that he reverently protected the encroachment of the Mau Complex, leading to drastic deforestation and destruction of wetlands. Water levels have declined in 12 rivers – Njoro, Molo, Nderit, Makalia, Naishi, Kerio, Mara, Ewaso Nyiro, Sondu, Nyando, Yala and Nzoia – that drain from the Mau Complex. Despite denying that the 90-day ban is not a PR stunt, the mandate of the task force he created remains obtuse to inter alia review forestry management and recommend ways depleted forests can be restored to achieve the constitutional 10 per cent cover. It’s duplicity since forest management agencies abound. Meanwhile, the moratorium he ordered against logging is also legally suspect. The President can issue an Executive Order to Cabinet Secretaries, but the DP has no such authority. That leaves the order an empty wayside threat unless the Kenya Forest Service is arm-twisted to adopt it through a task force. It’s not lack of legal instruments against disafforestation that necessitates creation of a task force. There is just lax enforcement of policies that deliberately creates loopholes for rent-seeking. In fact, the moratorium is just such an opportunity that will increase rent-seeking and expose the KFS to myriad litigation. Logging is a multibillion shilling industry. One doesn’t quite understand how the 90-day ban was arrived at and what it’s meant to achieve. Is it to allow newly planted seedlings to grow? Will the forest farmers be evicted? What difference does it make felling mature trees now or after 90 days? Will the logging licences be validated? What about the corruption chain inbuilt in logging licensing? With the moratorium, many brokers, saw millers, politicians, community leaders and forestry workers are holding logging licences that may become redundant. They will go down fighting. The ban on charcoal harvesting has ballooned into inter-county ethnic hostilities, if wood harvesting is mishandled it could implode into uncontrollable violence. Which means there is a ruse in this thing; timber prices are soaring. Who stands to make a killing? Obviously someone is creating artificial shortage of timber products to reap big, and the beneficiaries will be a select politically connected few and those who pay a bribe. Stockists who had the product will make a killing. What of the peasant forest dweller who has made it his home and livelihood? Do you just expunge them? Massive destruction of water towers courtesy of corruption has depleted the forest cover. The Constitution promises 10 per cent cover of our landmass, but the KFS serves ...
Read More


Category: oped opinion news

Suggested

17 hours ago, 12:33
@TheEastAfrican - By: Charles Onyango-o ...
Revolution starts on the heads of serious activists

The beret has a long pedigree, but it never captured the imagination of our activists. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
15 hours ago, 14:13
@DailyNation - By: Abigail Arunga
Why you might consider getting into Kenya in a motorbike and avoid flying into JKIA

Landing at JKIA, especially aboard Kenya Airways, can be such a nightmare. ...

Category: oped opinion news
17 hours ago, 12:52
@DailyNation - By: John Walubengo
High unemployment rate, but where are the appropriate skills?

We must choose to bridge the gap between industry and academia, or continue witnessing the blame game between the two stakeholders in the economy. ...

Category: oped opinion news
19 hours ago, 10:27
@TheStar - By: Star Editor
Natural resources must be shared

Lately, there has been heated exchange, especially among politicians, on the tapping and use of natural resources. One that has captured national attention involves Nairobi governor Mike Sonko and his ...

Category: oped opinion news
1 day ago, 21:59
@DailyNation - By: Macharia Gaitho
War on graft, crime more open but beware of false reportage

We just can’t afford to swallow and regurgitate every morsel from the police. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
1 day ago, 21:59
@DailyNation - By: Peter Ngare
Why Uhuru-Raila handshake has hurt the common Kenyan

To Maina, Ochieng’, Amina and Kamene, while the handshake has rendered them voiceless. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion

@TheStar

Ruto logging ban is a costly PR ploy

8 months ago, 8 Mar 00:38

By: Kibisu Kabatesi
The newfound eagerness by Deputy President William Ruto to preserve forests, like everything else he does, smacks of mischief. Ruto may be a champion of many things, but environment is not one of them. Not when he fought like a baited cat against the preservation of the Mau water tower not long ago. Not also when public perception has it there is no land he didn’t salivate over. And I loved it when he let slip the sound bite that his “track record on environment is known”. This notwithstanding that he reverently protected the encroachment of the Mau Complex, leading to drastic deforestation and destruction of wetlands. Water levels have declined in 12 rivers – Njoro, Molo, Nderit, Makalia, Naishi, Kerio, Mara, Ewaso Nyiro, Sondu, Nyando, Yala and Nzoia – that drain from the Mau Complex. Despite denying that the 90-day ban is not a PR stunt, the mandate of the task force he created remains obtuse to inter alia review forestry management and recommend ways depleted forests can be restored to achieve the constitutional 10 per cent cover. It’s duplicity since forest management agencies abound. Meanwhile, the moratorium he ordered against logging is also legally suspect. The President can issue an Executive Order to Cabinet Secretaries, but the DP has no such authority. That leaves the order an empty wayside threat unless the Kenya Forest Service is arm-twisted to adopt it through a task force. It’s not lack of legal instruments against disafforestation that necessitates creation of a task force. There is just lax enforcement of policies that deliberately creates loopholes for rent-seeking. In fact, the moratorium is just such an opportunity that will increase rent-seeking and expose the KFS to myriad litigation. Logging is a multibillion shilling industry. One doesn’t quite understand how the 90-day ban was arrived at and what it’s meant to achieve. Is it to allow newly planted seedlings to grow? Will the forest farmers be evicted? What difference does it make felling mature trees now or after 90 days? Will the logging licences be validated? What about the corruption chain inbuilt in logging licensing? With the moratorium, many brokers, saw millers, politicians, community leaders and forestry workers are holding logging licences that may become redundant. They will go down fighting. The ban on charcoal harvesting has ballooned into inter-county ethnic hostilities, if wood harvesting is mishandled it could implode into uncontrollable violence. Which means there is a ruse in this thing; timber prices are soaring. Who stands to make a killing? Obviously someone is creating artificial shortage of timber products to reap big, and the beneficiaries will be a select politically connected few and those who pay a bribe. Stockists who had the product will make a killing. What of the peasant forest dweller who has made it his home and livelihood? Do you just expunge them? Massive destruction of water towers courtesy of corruption has depleted the forest cover. The Constitution promises 10 per cent cover of our landmass, but the KFS serves ...
Read More

Category: oped opinion news

Suggested

17 hours ago, 12:33
@TheEastAfrican - By: Charles Onyango-o ...
Revolution starts on the heads of serious activists

The beret has a long pedigree, but it never captured the imagination of our activists. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
15 hours ago, 14:13
@DailyNation - By: Abigail Arunga
Why you might consider getting into Kenya in a motorbike and avoid flying into JKIA

Landing at JKIA, especially aboard Kenya Airways, can be such a nightmare. ...

Category: oped opinion news
17 hours ago, 12:52
@DailyNation - By: John Walubengo
High unemployment rate, but where are the appropriate skills?

We must choose to bridge the gap between industry and academia, or continue witnessing the blame game between the two stakeholders in the economy. ...

Category: oped opinion news
19 hours ago, 10:27
@TheStar - By: Star Editor
Natural resources must be shared

Lately, there has been heated exchange, especially among politicians, on the tapping and use of natural resources. One that has captured national attention involves Nairobi governor Mike Sonko and his ...

Category: oped opinion news
1 day ago, 21:59
@DailyNation - By: Macharia Gaitho
War on graft, crime more open but beware of false reportage

We just can’t afford to swallow and regurgitate every morsel from the police. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
1 day ago, 21:59
@DailyNation - By: Peter Ngare
Why Uhuru-Raila handshake has hurt the common Kenyan

To Maina, Ochieng’, Amina and Kamene, while the handshake has rendered them voiceless. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
Our App