@BusinessDaily

Battle over legality of CDF moves to the Supreme Court

12 months ago, 3 Jan 19:15

By: Galgallo Fayo

The battle over legality of the Constituency Development Fund (CDF) has moved to the Supreme Court, which is now set to have the final say on the kitty that Members of Parliament use to wield influence on community development projects. The move to the apex court marks yet another significant step in a protracted quest by two non-governmental organisations to have the fund declared illegal. The Court of Appeal last month overturned a 2015 High Court judgment that had declared CDF unconstitutional. The Institute for Social Accountability (TISA) and the Centre for Enhancing Democracy and Good Governance (CEDGG) have argued that CDF is unconstitutional in that MPs are involved in implementing tax-payer funded projects, which is a preserve of the executive arm of government. The kitty, which has since been renamed the National Government Constituency Development Fund (NGCDF) has been a political lifeline for MPs at the grassroots. The lobby groups claim that Court of Appeal judges failed to appreciate that, in effect, the CDF Act introduced a third entity to compete for financial resources with the national and county governments effectively and unconstitutionally introducing a third-tier of devolution. They claim in the appeal filed at the Supreme Court that Court of Appeal judges failed to find that the CDF Act 2013, through the language it employed, enabled the national government to encroach upon the constitutional functions of the county governments. They want the finding of Appeal court to be overturned and the High Court judgment upheld. The High Court had in 2015 also found that the Constitution had been violated by failure to involve the Senate when the law was amended in 2013. The High Court judges had also said the Act threatens to upset the division of functions between the national and county levels of governments and interfere with county government’s autonomy. The Court of Appeal judges, however, held that the petition raised hypothetical questions since neither county nor national governments had raised any dispute. The High Court judges despite far-reaching findings magnanimously allowed lawmakers to correct the defective legislation within 12 months. The Court of Appeal further held that the High Court erred when it found that the CDF fund ought to have been in the form of a grant as conditional revenue to county governments or through existing county government structures. The court also held that it was improbable that CDF would interfere with county governments’ planning or autonomy. The appointment of Members of Parliament to perform purely executive duties of enforcing the CDF Act, 2013, was found contrary to the principle of separation of powers and of the national values and governance.
Read More


Category: business news corporate economy opinion markets lifestyle

Suggested

15 hours ago, 18:05
@BusinessDaily - By: Patrick Alushula
Lobby sees revenue loopholes in treaties

East Africa Tax and Governance Network says double taxation agreements (DTAs) between Kenya and other countries come with little disclosure and may be exposing the country to tax leakages. ...

Category: business news opinion
15 hours ago, 18:05
@BusinessDaily - By: Charles Mwaniki
Treasury back in market for Sh14bn after initial bond flop

The Treasury is back in the market with a Sh13.8 billion tap sale for this month’s bond issue, after the initial sale was undersubscribed by 28 percent. ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Kiragu Kariuki
LETTERS: Goat farming can help tackle food insecurity

Frequency in drought occurrence and climate change have constrained both agricultural and livestock production sectors exposing many households to food insecurity yearly. ...

Category: business news opinion
15 hours ago, 18:06
@BusinessDaily - By: Mwangi Muiruri
Nyandarua in Sh400m potato factory plan

Nyandarua County has set aside Sh400 million for construction of a potato value-addition plant at Shamata. Governor Francis Kimemia said the project will commence in January with a completion date of ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Tom Mulwa,
MULWA: Time to plan for health needs after retirement

Life after retirement comes with special health-related challenges. ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Jenny Lues
LUESBY: Banks need thorough regulation

My youngest son has a bunch of songs he trots out, each for the right moment. ...

Category: business news opinion

@BusinessDaily

Battle over legality of CDF moves to the Supreme Court

12 months ago, 3 Jan 19:15

By: Galgallo Fayo
The battle over legality of the Constituency Development Fund (CDF) has moved to the Supreme Court, which is now set to have the final say on the kitty that Members of Parliament use to wield influence on community development projects. The move to the apex court marks yet another significant step in a protracted quest by two non-governmental organisations to have the fund declared illegal. The Court of Appeal last month overturned a 2015 High Court judgment that had declared CDF unconstitutional. The Institute for Social Accountability (TISA) and the Centre for Enhancing Democracy and Good Governance (CEDGG) have argued that CDF is unconstitutional in that MPs are involved in implementing tax-payer funded projects, which is a preserve of the executive arm of government. The kitty, which has since been renamed the National Government Constituency Development Fund (NGCDF) has been a political lifeline for MPs at the grassroots. The lobby groups claim that Court of Appeal judges failed to appreciate that, in effect, the CDF Act introduced a third entity to compete for financial resources with the national and county governments effectively and unconstitutionally introducing a third-tier of devolution. They claim in the appeal filed at the Supreme Court that Court of Appeal judges failed to find that the CDF Act 2013, through the language it employed, enabled the national government to encroach upon the constitutional functions of the county governments. They want the finding of Appeal court to be overturned and the High Court judgment upheld. The High Court had in 2015 also found that the Constitution had been violated by failure to involve the Senate when the law was amended in 2013. The High Court judges had also said the Act threatens to upset the division of functions between the national and county levels of governments and interfere with county government’s autonomy. The Court of Appeal judges, however, held that the petition raised hypothetical questions since neither county nor national governments had raised any dispute. The High Court judges despite far-reaching findings magnanimously allowed lawmakers to correct the defective legislation within 12 months. The Court of Appeal further held that the High Court erred when it found that the CDF fund ought to have been in the form of a grant as conditional revenue to county governments or through existing county government structures. The court also held that it was improbable that CDF would interfere with county governments’ planning or autonomy. The appointment of Members of Parliament to perform purely executive duties of enforcing the CDF Act, 2013, was found contrary to the principle of separation of powers and of the national values and governance.
Read More

Category: business news corporate economy opinion markets lifestyle

Suggested

15 hours ago, 18:05
@BusinessDaily - By: Patrick Alushula
Lobby sees revenue loopholes in treaties

East Africa Tax and Governance Network says double taxation agreements (DTAs) between Kenya and other countries come with little disclosure and may be exposing the country to tax leakages. ...

Category: business news opinion
15 hours ago, 18:05
@BusinessDaily - By: Charles Mwaniki
Treasury back in market for Sh14bn after initial bond flop

The Treasury is back in the market with a Sh13.8 billion tap sale for this month’s bond issue, after the initial sale was undersubscribed by 28 percent. ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Kiragu Kariuki
LETTERS: Goat farming can help tackle food insecurity

Frequency in drought occurrence and climate change have constrained both agricultural and livestock production sectors exposing many households to food insecurity yearly. ...

Category: business news opinion
15 hours ago, 18:06
@BusinessDaily - By: Mwangi Muiruri
Nyandarua in Sh400m potato factory plan

Nyandarua County has set aside Sh400 million for construction of a potato value-addition plant at Shamata. Governor Francis Kimemia said the project will commence in January with a completion date of ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Tom Mulwa,
MULWA: Time to plan for health needs after retirement

Life after retirement comes with special health-related challenges. ...

Category: business news opinion
16 hours ago, 16:20
@BusinessDaily - By: Jenny Lues
LUESBY: Banks need thorough regulation

My youngest son has a bunch of songs he trots out, each for the right moment. ...

Category: business news opinion
Our App